Your bid didn't lose on price. It lost on a category you never saw.
Facilities managers rarely explain why a cleaning bid was passed over. Most contractors assume it was price and cut margin next time — which is usually the wrong fix.
See the discovery questions that surface this before you bid
The silence after a lost bid is the real problem
You submit a proposal, follow up twice, and hear nothing back — or a two-line rejection with no reason. That silence isn't personal. Most procurement processes, from a one-page RFQ to a formal RFP, run through an internal scoring sheet the building never shares with vendors. If you don't know the categories on that sheet, you can't tell whether you lost on price, on paperwork, or on something you could have fixed in ten minutes.
This page lays out the categories that show up again and again in how commercial buildings actually score janitorial proposals, so you can check your own bid against them before you submit instead of guessing after you lose.
What's actually on the scoring sheet
Price is one line item, not the whole decision — even when the RFP says 'lowest responsible bidder.'
Price and pricing structure
Not just the total — whether your pricing is broken out by task, frequency, and add-on so a facilities manager can defend the number to their own boss. A single lump sum reads as less rigorous than a broken-down bid, even at the same price.
Staffing and supervision plan
Who's actually on site, how many hours, who supervises them, and what happens when someone calls out. Buildings that had a bad experience with high turnover weight this heavily and often won't say so upfront.
References and tenure with similar buildings
Not references in general — references from buildings of a similar size and type to theirs. A strong reference from a small retail space carries little weight for a 12-floor Class A office bid.
Insurance, bonding, and compliance paperwork
Missing or expired certificates are an automatic disqualifier at many buildings before anyone reads the price. See our insurance and bonding page for what's typically required.
Transition plan
How you take over from the incumbent without a gap in service or a rocky first month. Bids that don't address this read as inexperienced, even from experienced contractors who just didn't write it down.
Quality control and reporting
How you catch problems before the tenant complains — walkthroughs, checklists, a way to log and resolve issues. This is increasingly a written requirement, not an assumption.
How to fix a proposal before you resubmit anywhere
Same offer, same price — restructured so a facilities manager can score it instead of guessing.
-
Break out the price
Show base cleaning, frequency options, and add-ons as separate line items, not one number. Use the same structure across every bid so it's easy to compare and easy for them to defend internally.
-
Write the staffing plan down
State headcount, hours on site, supervisor name or role, and your callout/backup coverage plan. One paragraph is enough — the point is that it's there in writing, not implied.
-
Match your references to the building
If you don't have a reference from a similar building type or size, say what you do have honestly rather than stretching a mismatched one. A believable near-match beats an inflated exact one.
-
Attach current certificates, not 'available on request'
Insurance certificate, bonding, workers' comp — attach them to the bid itself. 'Available on request' reads as friction to someone screening ten proposals.
-
Add a one-page transition plan
First week, first month, who's the point of contact, how issues get reported. This single addition differentiates a proposal more than another percentage point off the price.
Common questions about lost bids
The building said it was 'the lowest bid.' Was price really the whole reason?
Sometimes, especially for small single-tenant contracts with no formal RFP. For anything with a written proposal process, 'lowest bid' is usually shorthand for 'lowest bid that also cleared the other categories' — and you rarely find out which category was borderline.
Should I ask for feedback after losing a bid?
Yes, briefly and without pushing. A short 'is there anything about the proposal I could improve for next time' email sometimes gets a real answer, especially from a facilities manager you'd want to bid for again next renewal cycle.
Is it worth rewriting my staffing and transition plan for every bid, or should I template it?
Template the structure, customize the specifics. A generic staffing plan that doesn't reference the actual building's square footage or hours reads as copy-pasted — which undermines the credibility the section was supposed to build.
Does a lower price ever lose to a higher one on purpose?
Often, yes — particularly for multi-year contracts where the building has been burned by a cheap bid before. Buildings that have gone through a bad contractor transition will frequently pay more for a proposal that reads as operationally solid.
Fix the proposal before the next one goes out
Start from a structure built for this, not a blank document.